Swept wings and the area rule – Navigation and Technology aviation lesson
Lesson 33 of 90 in the Navigation and Technology course (ages 14+)
US version. US spelling and units (inHg, statute miles, US gallons) and the FAA. · UK version
Why do jet airliners have wings that slant backwards, and why did one 1950s fighter only go supersonic after its body was given a 'waist'? Find out how designers tamed the shock waves that appear near the speed of sound.
- Time
- 45 minutes + 10 min homework
- Course
- Navigation and Technology (ages 14+)
- You need
- Paper, a pencil and this page
- Graded
- Instantly, with explanations
Education and interest only. Classfern teaches aviation as a school subject. It is not flight training, not an FAA-approved school, and nothing here counts towards a pilot certificate or replaces training with a certificated instructor and the FAA knowledge test.
How to use this lesson
Sources: US Centennial of Flight Commission essay on transonic wings and the area rule; Smithsonian Air & Space magazine article on Richard Whitcomb; FAA Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge, chapter 5 (Mach number and speed ranges). Good practice in ratios and squares for GCSE or high-school math. Every answer is graded straight away with a worked explanation.
- Read what you will learn and the big ideas.
- Press Start the lesson below for the teaching, worked examples and practice (Getting started, On track or Challenge).
- Finish with the exit ticket and the talk question: “Whitcomb's idea came from thinking about the whole aircraft as one shape, not as separate wings and body. Can you think of another problem where looking at the whole thing, not its parts, gives the answer?”
- Later: the homework, then the practice test.
Watch out for
- Thinking shock waves only appear once the aircraft itself passes Mach 1. Air speeds up over the wing, so shocks can form at the critical Mach number, well below Mach 1.
- Thinking swept wings are just for looks. Sweep delays the critical Mach number and cuts wave drag – it has a clear aerodynamic job.
- Thinking the area rule is about making the aircraft smaller. It is about making the cross-sectional area change smoothly along the length, not about the total size.
Hands-on: Cut out ten paper discs of different sizes and line them up on a table in order, as if they were slices through an aircraft from nose to tail. Draw a graph of disc size against position. Now add two 'wing' slices that suddenly make the middle discs much bigger. Can you shrink the 'body' slices in the middle so the graph becomes a smooth hill again? That is the area rule.
What you will learn
- I can explain what happens to airflow as an aircraft nears the speed of sound.
- I can explain why swept wings delay shock waves, and one drawback of sweep.
- I can describe the area rule and how it changed fuselage shapes.
- I can calculate Mach numbers and the effect of wing thickness on drag rise.
Key words
- Mach number
- True airspeed divided by the local speed of sound. Mach 1 is the speed of sound.
- critical Mach number
- The flight Mach number at which the airflow somewhere on the aircraft first reaches the speed of sound.
- transonic
- The speed range around Mach 1 where some of the airflow is subsonic and some supersonic – roughly Mach 0.75 to 1.20.
- sweep
- Angling a wing backwards (or forward) from the fuselage instead of straight out sideways.
- area rule
- The design idea that drag near and above Mach 1 is lowest when the aircraft's cross-sectional area changes smoothly from nose to tail.
The big ideas
As an aircraft speeds up, the air flowing over the curved top of its wing speeds up even more. Long before the aircraft itself reaches the speed of sound, some of that air does. The FAA's Pilot's Handbook calls the flight speed at which this first happens the critical Mach number. Beyond it, shock waves form, drag rises steeply, and the controls can behave strangely. The Handbook calls the band from about Mach 0.75 to 1.20 'transonic'.
In 1935 the German aerodynamicist Adolf Busemann suggested a way round this: sweep the wing. The US Centennial of Flight Commission explains that sweep delays shock waves to a higher Mach number, because the air 'sees' a wing that is effectively thinner and has more time to adjust. That is why almost every jet airliner has swept wings. Sweep has a price: the Commission notes that swept-back wings tend to stall at the tips first, which can take away aileron control, so designers add twist and small fences on the wing.
In 1951 Richard Whitcomb, working at the US research agency NACA (NASA's forerunner), had another insight. Near Mach 1, the air does not care whether a bulge is wing or body – it reacts to how the total cross-sectional area grows and shrinks along the aircraft. Pinching the fuselage in where the wings join keeps the total smooth. Smithsonian magazine says this roughly halved the drag rise. A US delta-wing fighter, the F-102, could not go supersonic until it was redesigned with a narrow 'waist'. Whitcomb won America's top aviation prize, the Collier Trophy, for the idea in 1954.
Read-through: the teaching steps
Air speeds up over a wing
Air over the curved upper surface travels faster than the aircraft. So a jet flying at, say, Mach 0.8 can have air at Mach 1 over part of its wing. That flight speed is its critical Mach number.
Shock waves and drag rise
Above the critical Mach number, small shock waves form on the wing. The Centennial of Flight Commission notes that the extra drag grows roughly with the square of the wing's thickness-to-chord ratio – so thin wings help a lot.
The swept wing
- Proposed by Adolf Busemann in 1935.
- Delays the critical Mach number and reduces wave drag.
- Works because the wing 'looks' thinner to the airflow.
Forward sweep works too, but the Commission notes it has its own low-speed handling problems.
The catch: tip stall
On a swept-back wing, the slow air near the surface drifts outwards towards the tips. The tips can then stall first, and the ailerons there lose their grip. Designers fight this with wing twist and small upright stall fences.
The area rule
Whitcomb's 1951 idea: plot the aircraft's cross-sectional area from nose to tail. If the curve has a sudden jump where the wings start, drag near Mach 1 is high. Squeeze the fuselage where the wings are, and add bulges further back if needed, until the curve is smooth.
The fighter that needed a waist
The Commission records that the first F-102 design had a big jump in area at the wings and so much transonic drag that the project was nearly canceled. Redesigned with a narrowed waist and bulges behind the wing, it went supersonic and entered service in large numbers.
Whitcomb's later ideas
Around 1962 Whitcomb went on to the supercritical wing: a flatter top and a curled-down trailing edge that hold back shock waves. Smithsonian magazine says such wings are now used on all new airliners and business jets, cruising at up to Mach 0.92.
The lesson, step by step
| Part | Time | How it is checked |
|---|---|---|
| Starter: warm up | 4 min | Graded by Classfern |
| Teaching and hands-on task | 14 min | Not assessed, self-checked |
| Worked examples and guided practice | 9 min | Graded by Classfern |
| Independent practice (three levels) | 13 min | Graded by Classfern |
| Exit ticket and talk question | 5 min | Graded by Classfern, self-checked |
Make my lesson plan Opens this lesson in the free Lesson Plan Maker, filled in and ready to change, print or save.
The lesson
It runs here on the page. No sign-up and no names – progress is kept only in this browser.
Homework
About 10 minutes: 6 questions and a one-line reflection, all graded instantly.
More practice
More Aircraft technology lessons · Navigation and Technology course · All aviation practice tests · Aviation Department
Sources and curriculum
Facts in this lesson were checked against:
- U.S. Centennial of Flight Commission – essays on aviation history
- Smithsonian Air & Space magazine – The man who could see air
- FAA Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge FAA-H-8083-25C
Our lessons and questions are our own. They are not written or endorsed by the FAA, any flying school, testing agency or exam board.