▶ TrainingGet Pro
All tools & lessonsAll toolsAllGet the appApp
Learning departments Music, Math, Cookery, Programming and Art are open – explore →

From wing warping to ailerons – Navigation and Technology aviation lesson

Lesson 29 of 90 in the Navigation and Technology course (ages 14+)

US version. US spelling and units (inHg, statute miles, US gallons) and the FAA. · UK version

How do you make an aircraft roll? The Wright brothers twisted their whole wing; within a few years others used hinged flaps called ailerons – and a famous legal battle followed. Discover how roll control works, why it caused a strange spinning problem, and how a linked rudder solved it.

Time
40 minutes + 10 min homework
Course
Navigation and Technology (ages 14+)
You need
Paper, a pencil and this page
Graded
Instantly, with explanations

Education and interest only. Classfern teaches aviation as a school subject. It is not flight training, not an FAA-approved school, and nothing here counts towards a pilot certificate or replaces training with a certificated instructor and the FAA knowledge test.

How to use this lesson

Sources: US Centennial of Flight Commission essays on the 1902 glider and the Wright patent battles; FAA Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge chapter 6 (ailerons and adverse yaw). Glenn Curtiss and Alexander Graham Bell appear as historical figures. Every answer is graded straight away with a worked explanation.

  1. Read what you will learn and the big ideas.
  2. Press Start the lesson below for the teaching, worked examples and practice (Getting started, On track or Challenge).
  3. Finish with the exit ticket and the talk question: “The Wrights spent years in court defending their patent, while others built better aircraft. Do patents help or hold back invention?”
  4. Later: the homework, then the practice test.

Watch out for

  • Thinking ailerons turn an aircraft on their own. Ailerons bank the aircraft; the tilted lift turns it, and rudder is used to stop adverse yaw.
  • Thinking both ailerons go up together. They move in opposite directions: one up, one down.
  • Thinking wing warping is still common. Stiff metal wings can't be twisted, so almost all modern aircraft use ailerons (or spoilers).

Hands-on: Make a paper glider and cut two small flaps at the back of each wingtip. Bend one flap up and the other down, and throw it gently. Which way does it roll? Now twist the wingtips instead of bending flaps – does warping do the same thing?

What you will learn

  • I can explain how wing warping and ailerons both control roll.
  • I can explain why the 1902 glider needed a movable rudder (three-axis control).
  • I can explain adverse yaw and why rudder is used with ailerons.
  • I can describe the patent dispute over lateral control.

Key words

roll
Rotation about the line from nose to tail, lowering one wing and raising the other.
wing warping
Twisting the wingtips in opposite directions with wires so one wing gets more lift and the other less.
aileron
A hinged flap near the wingtip; one goes up while the other goes down, to roll the aircraft.
adverse yaw
The nose swinging the 'wrong' way, towards the rising wing, because the wing with more lift also has more drag.
three-axis control
Being able to control pitch, roll and yaw separately.

The big ideas

To turn, an aircraft banks – it rolls so that one wing is lower than the other. The Wright brothers solved roll control by wing warping: wires twisted the wingtips in opposite directions, so one wing met the air at a bigger angle and gained lift while the other lost it. But warping brought a surprise. The US Centennial of Flight Commission explains that on their early gliders the wing with more lift also had more drag, the glider skidded, and it could slide into an uncontrolled spiral the brothers called 'well-digging'.

The cure came in 1902. Orville proposed a movable rudder; Wilbur suggested linking its wires to the warping system. On October 6, 1902, a single movable rudder replaced the fixed double tail. With an elevator for pitch, warping for roll and the rudder for yaw, the Commission calls the 1902 glider the world's first aircraft with three-axis control. The brothers made almost 1,000 glides that fall, the best covering 622 ft in 26 seconds.

Others soon used ailerons – hinged flaps near the wingtips – instead of twisting the wing. On July 4, 1908, Glenn Curtiss flew the June Bug with wingtip panels based on Alexander Graham Bell's aileron idea. The Wrights' 1906 patent covered lateral control, and they sued. In 1913 a court found for Orville Wright, but during World War I aircraft makers formed a government-approved patent pool and the lawsuits stopped. Ailerons won in the end because stiff metal wings cannot be twisted, and the FAA's Pilot's Handbook still explains that rudder is used with ailerons to counter adverse yaw.

Read-through: the teaching steps

  1. Rolling to turn

    An aircraft turns by banking: tilting its lift sideways. To bank, one wing must make more lift than the other. Roll happens about the longitudinal axis (nose to tail), as the control surfaces drawing on the lesson page shows.

    Aileron (roll)Aileron (roll)Elevator (pitch)Rudder on fin (yaw)
    Ailerons roll the aircraft, the elevator pitches it and the rudder yaws it.
  2. Wing warping

    Wires twisted the wingtips in opposite directions.

    • One tip twisted up at the front: bigger angle, more lift.
    • The other twisted down: smaller angle, less lift.

    The Wrights may have got the idea from twisting a long cardboard box.

  3. The 'well-digging' problem

    The wing with more lift also had more drag, so it was held back. The aircraft yawed the wrong way and skidded. With a fixed tail dragging, the inside wing slowed, lost lift and the glider spiraled down.

  4. Three-axis control

    A movable rudder linked to the warping cured it in October 1902. Now:

    • elevator – pitch
    • warping – roll
    • rudder – yaw

    The Commission calls this the world's first three-axis control system.

  5. Ailerons arrive

    Ailerons are hinged flaps near the wingtips. One goes down (more lift), the other up (less lift). They do the same job as warping without twisting the wing – ideal for stiffer, stronger wings. The PHAK explains designs such as differential and Frise-type ailerons that reduce adverse yaw.

  6. The patent fight

    The Wrights' 1906 patent covered lateral control. They sued makers who used ailerons. A 1913 verdict favored Orville Wright, but a wartime patent pool ended the lawsuits, with royalties cut to one per cent.

The lesson, step by step

40 minutes in 5 parts
PartTimeHow it is checked
Starter: warm up4 minGraded by Classfern
Teaching and hands-on task12 minNot assessed, self-checked
Worked examples and guided practice8 minGraded by Classfern
Independent practice (three levels)11 minGraded by Classfern
Exit ticket and talk question5 minGraded by Classfern, self-checked

Make my lesson plan Opens this lesson in the free Lesson Plan Maker, filled in and ready to change, print or save.

The lesson

It runs here on the page. No sign-up and no names – progress is kept only in this browser.

Homework

About 10 minutes: 6 questions and a one-line reflection, all graded instantly.

More practice

More Aircraft technology lessons · Navigation and Technology course · All aviation practice tests · Aviation Department

Sources and curriculum

Facts in this lesson were checked against:

Our lessons and questions are our own. They are not written or endorsed by the FAA, any flying school, testing agency or exam board.