Pressurisation and the Comet lessons – Navigation and Technology aviation lesson
Lesson 32 of 90 in the Navigation and Technology course (ages 14+)
UK version. UK spelling and units (hPa, metres, litres) and the UK CAA. · US version
The world's first jet airliner flew higher and faster than anything before it – and then three broke up in the air. Find out how a cabin is kept at a comfortable pressure, what metal fatigue is, and how a water tank test changed aircraft design for ever.
- Time
- 45 minutes + 10 min homework
- Course
- Navigation and Technology (ages 14+)
- You need
- Paper, a pencil and this page
- Marked
- Instantly, with explanations
Education and interest only. Classfern teaches aviation as a school subject. It is not flight training, not an approved training organisation, and nothing here counts towards a pilot licence or replaces a CAA-approved course and the CAA’s own exams.
How to use this lesson
Sources: FAA Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge, chapter 7 (pressurised aircraft); FAA Lessons Learned report on the Comet accidents; National Museums Scotland Comet 4C story. The topic includes fatal accidents; it is handled factually, with the focus on what was learned. Every answer is marked straight away with a worked explanation.
- Read what you will learn and the big ideas.
- Press Start the lesson below for the teaching, worked examples and practice (Getting started, On track or Challenge).
- Finish with the exit ticket and the talk question: “Investigators tested a whole airliner in a water tank to find the cause of the accidents. Why do you think sharing what they learned with the rest of the world mattered so much?”
- Later: the homework, then the practice test.
Watch out for
- Thinking the Comets broke up because the metal was too weak to hold the pressure once. Each flight was well within its strength. The problem was fatigue: cracks growing a little on every one of many flights.
- Thinking the cabin is kept at sea-level pressure. The Handbook says a typical cabin altitude is about 8,000 ft at maximum cruise, which keeps the differential, and the stress, lower.
- Thinking a strong test result always means the real aircraft is safe. The Comet prototype had been toughened by an earlier overload test. Test parts must match production parts.
Hands-on: Take a paper clip and straighten it. Bend the middle back and forth, counting the bends, until it snaps. Try again with a second clip, but put a sharp kink in it first. Which breaks after fewer bends? Then cut two shapes from a piece of thin card – one with a square hole and one with a round hole – and gently pull each until it tears. Where does the tear start?
What you will learn
- I can explain why airliners fly high and why their cabins must be pressurised.
- I can calculate a cabin pressure differential from given figures.
- I can explain what metal fatigue is and why square corners concentrate stress.
- I can describe the safe-life, fail-safe and damage-tolerance ideas that came from the Comet investigation.
Key words
- cabin altitude
- The height in the standard atmosphere whose air pressure matches the pressure inside the cabin.
- pressure differential
- The difference between the pressure inside the cabin and the pressure outside, often in psi.
- metal fatigue
- Weakening of metal by repeated loading and unloading, so that cracks grow even though each load is well below breaking strength.
- stress concentration
- A place, such as a sharp corner, where the load in a structure bunches up and becomes much higher than nearby.
- outflow valve
- A valve that lets air leave the cabin at a controlled rate, so fresh air keeps flowing in and the pressure stays where it is set.
The big ideas
Jet airliners fly high because, as the FAA's Pilot's Handbook explains, they use less fuel there and can fly above much of the bad weather. But the air up there is too thin to breathe for long. So the cabin is pumped up with air taken from the jet engines' compressors, and an outflow valve lets it out at a controlled rate. The Handbook says a typical system keeps the cabin at a pressure altitude of about 8,000 ft when the aircraft is at its highest cruising level. At 28,000 ft the outside pressure is 4.8 psi; pumping the cabin 6.1 psi above that gives 10.9 psi – the same as standing on a mountain at 8,000 ft.
That pressure difference pushes outwards on every part of the fuselage, and it is applied and removed on every flight, like blowing up and letting down a balloon. The Comet – National Museums Scotland calls it the world's first commercial passenger jet – carried its first paying passengers on 2 May 1952. Then, on 10 January 1954, one broke up near Elba while climbing through 27,000 ft, and on 8 April 1954 another came down near Naples.
The FAA's Lessons Learned report describes what investigators did next. They put a whole Comet fuselage in a water tank and pressurised it again and again. After about 3,060 flights' worth of pressure (in the air and in the tank) it split open at the corner of a squarish window. The repeated loading had grown a fatigue crack where the stress bunched up at a sharp corner. Today's oval windows, crack-stopping structure and careful fatigue testing all come from that lesson. Airline flights restarted about four years later with the redesigned Comet 4.
Read-through: the teaching steps
Why fly high?
The Pilot's Handbook gives two reasons: less fuel for the same airspeed, and the chance to fly above storms and turbulence. The price is thin air, so the people inside need either a pressurised cabin or extra oxygen.
How a cabin is pressurised
- Air is taken from the jet engines' compressors (bleed air) and fed into the cabin.
- An outflow valve lets air out at a controlled rate, so fresh air keeps flowing through.
- A regulator sets the pressure; a safety valve stops the difference ever getting too big.
The fuselage is designed for a maximum pressure differential, and the system keeps below it.
Working out the differential
Differential = cabin pressure − outside pressure.
Handbook example: outside at 28,000 ft = 4.8 psi; cabin at 8,000 ft cabin altitude = 10.9 psi; differential = 10.9 − 4.8 = 6.1 psi.
6.1 psi on every square inch of a large fuselage adds up to a very large outward push.
Metal fatigue
Bend a paper clip once and it is fine. Bend it back and forth and it snaps – even though no single bend was too much. Metal in a fuselage is loaded and unloaded on every flight, and tiny cracks can grow a little each time. Sharp corners make it worse, because the stress bunches up there.
The water tank test
- The test fuselage had already made 1,230 pressurised flights.
- In the tank it failed after 1,830 more pressure cycles – about 3,060 in all.
- The crack started at the corner of a squarish window.
Why the earlier test missed it
The FAA report explains that the prototype fuselage was first pressure-tested to twice its working load, which toughened the window corners, and was then fatigue-tested to 16,000 cycles. Production aircraft, without that extra toughening, lasted only about 1,000 cycles against a target of 10,000. A test article must be like the real thing.
Lessons that still keep you safe
- Rounded (oval) windows to spread stress.
- Safe-life: parts given a set service life.
- Fail-safe: more than one load path, and crack stoppers, so one crack cannot bring down the structure.
- Damage tolerance: today's approach combining both, with inspections to find cracks long before they become dangerous.
The lesson, step by step
| Part | Time | How it is checked |
|---|---|---|
| Starter: warm up | 4 min | Marked by Classfern |
| Teaching and hands-on task | 14 min | Not assessed, self-checked |
| Worked examples and guided practice | 9 min | Marked by Classfern |
| Independent practice (three levels) | 13 min | Marked by Classfern |
| Exit ticket and talk question | 5 min | Marked by Classfern, self-checked |
Make my lesson plan Opens this lesson in the free Lesson Plan Maker, filled in and ready to change, print or save.
The lesson
It runs here on the page. No sign-up and no names – progress is kept only in this browser.
Homework
About 10 minutes: 6 questions and a one-line reflection, all marked instantly.
More practice
More Aircraft technology lessons · Navigation and Technology course · All aviation practice tests · Aviation Department
Sources and curriculum
Facts in this lesson were checked against:
- FAA Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge FAA-H-8083-25C
- FAA Lessons Learned from transport airplane accidents
- National Museums Scotland – Comet 4C story
Our lessons and questions are our own. They are not written or endorsed by the CAA, any flying school, testing agency or exam board.