Structures: stress, strain, fatigue and the Comet lesson – Ground School Basics aviation lesson
Lesson 28 of 90 in the Ground School Basics course (ages 11–16)
UK version. UK spelling and units (hPa, metres, litres) and the UK CAA. · US version
Learn what stress, strain and metal fatigue mean, and how the Comet accidents of 1954 changed the way every airliner is designed and tested.
- Time
- 45 minutes + 10 min homework
- Course
- Ground School Basics (ages 11–16)
- You need
- Paper, a pencil and this page
- Marked
- Instantly, with explanations
Education and interest only. Classfern teaches aviation as a school subject. It is not flight training, not an approved training organisation, and nothing here counts towards a pilot licence or replaces a CAA-approved course and the CAA’s own exams.
For parents: how to use this lesson
The Comet accidents caused loss of life; discuss them respectfully, focusing on how investigators learned and made flying safer. Card-tearing is a quick, safe way to see stress concentration. Every answer is marked straight away with a worked explanation.
- Read what your child will learn and the big ideas.
- Press Start the lesson below for the teaching, worked examples and practice (Getting started, On track or Challenge).
- Finish with the exit ticket and the talk question: “The Comet engineers did many tests before the aircraft entered service. Why do you think the danger was still missed, and what does that teach us about testing?”
- Later: the homework, then the practice test.
Watch out for
- Thinking a structure that survives one big test load will last forever. Fatigue comes from many repeated smaller loads. The Comet prototype passed strength tests but its windows cracked under repeated cycles.
- Mixing up stress and force. Stress is force per unit area. A bigger area spreads the force and lowers the stress.
- Thinking strain has units of metres. Strain is extension ÷ original length, so the units cancel.
Hands-on: Cut two shapes from thin card: one with a square hole, one with a round hole of the same size. Pull gently on each end until it tears. Note where each tear starts. Repeat three times and record whether tears start at corners.
What your child will learn
- I can calculate stress as force ÷ area and strain as extension ÷ original length.
- I can explain what metal fatigue is and why repeated loads matter.
- I can explain why sharp corners cause stress concentrations.
- I can describe how the Comet investigation changed aircraft testing and design.
Key words
- stress
- Force divided by the area it acts on, measured in pascals (N/m²).
- strain
- How much something stretches compared with its original length (extension ÷ original length); it has no units.
- fatigue
- Weakening of a material by many repeated load cycles, which can start and grow cracks even below the material's normal strength.
- stress concentration
- A spot, such as a sharp corner or hole, where stress is much higher than in the surrounding material.
- pressurisation cycle
- One flight's worth of pressurising the cabin and letting it down again; each cycle loads the fuselage.
- fail-safe
- A design approach where, if one part cracks, other parts carry the load so the structure does not fail.
The big ideas
Every time a pressurised airliner climbs, the fuselage is pushed outwards like a balloon; every time it lands, the load is removed. Engineers describe loads with stress (force ÷ area) and how much material stretches with strain (extension ÷ original length). One big load might be perfectly safe, but thousands of repeated smaller loads can slowly grow a crack. That is metal fatigue.
The de Havilland Comet 1 was the world's first pressurised jet transport, according to the FAA's Lessons Learned library. In 1954 two Comets broke up in the climb: one near Elba in January and one near Naples in April. A Comet fuselage (G-ALYU) was tested in a water tank, pressurised again and again. After about 3,060 pressurised cycles in total, it failed at the corner of a squarish window. The Elba aircraft had flown 1,290 pressurised flights; the Naples aircraft 900.
The lessons changed aviation: test a complete pressure cabin for fatigue; avoid sharp corners (later Comets had oval windows); and design so that one crack cannot bring down the aircraft – the ideas behind today's "damage tolerance" rules.
Read-through: the teaching steps
Stress
Stress = force ÷ area. The same force spread over a bigger area gives less stress. Stress is measured in pascals (Pa), where 1 Pa = 1 N/m².
Strain
Strain = extension ÷ original length. If a 2 m bar stretches by 1 mm (0.001 m), strain = 0.001 ÷ 2 = 0.0005. Strain has no units because it is length ÷ length.
Fatigue
A paper clip bent once is fine; bent back and forth many times it snaps. Repeated loading grows tiny cracks a little each cycle. In a pressurised fuselage each flight is one cycle.
Corners concentrate stress
A sharp corner or a hole makes the stress around it much higher than in the rest of the panel. The FAA says the stresses at the Comet's squarish window corners were far higher than the early calculations suggested.
The Comet investigation
- January 1954: Comet G-ALYP broke up climbing through 27,000 ft near Elba
- April 1954: G-ALYY broke up near Naples
- A fuselage, G-ALYU, was tested in a water tank – water is safer than air if the structure bursts
- It failed at a squarish escape-hatch window corner after about 3,060 cycles
- Elba wreckage showed the first crack at the squarish ADF windows on top of the fuselage
What changed
The Comet returned to airline service four years later as the Comet 4. UK rules later required fatigue tests on a complete pressure cabin. Comet windows became oval. Boeing's 707 used a "fail-safe" approach, and modern "damage tolerance" rules combine ideas so that cracks are found and contained before they become dangerous.
The lesson, step by step
| Part | Time | How it is checked |
|---|---|---|
| Starter: warm up | 4 min | Marked by Classfern |
| Teaching and hands-on task | 14 min | Not assessed, self-checked |
| Worked examples and guided practice | 9 min | Marked by Classfern |
| Independent practice (three levels) | 13 min | Marked by Classfern |
| Exit ticket and talk question | 5 min | Marked by Classfern, self-checked |
Make my lesson plan Opens this lesson in the free Lesson Plan Maker, filled in and ready to change, print or save.
The lesson
It runs here on the page. No sign-up and no names – progress is kept only in this browser.
Homework
About 10 minutes: 6 questions and a one-line reflection, all marked instantly.
More practice
More Physics of flight lessons · Ground School Basics course · All aviation practice tests · Aviation Department
Sources and curriculum
Facts in this lesson were checked against:
- FAA Lessons Learned from transport airplane accidents
- FAA Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge FAA-H-8083-25C
Our lessons and questions are our own. They are not written or endorsed by the CAA, any flying school, testing agency or exam board.