▶ TrainingGet Pro
All tools & lessonsAll toolsAllGet the appApp
Learning departments Music, Math, Cookery, Programming and Art are open – explore →

Birds versus planes: biomimicry – Navigation and Technology aviation lesson

Lesson 87 of 90 in the Navigation and Technology course (ages 14+)

US version. US spelling and units (inHg, statute miles, US gallons) and the FAA. · UK version

People watched birds for thousands of years before they flew. Find out what early aviators really learned from birds, where airplanes work quite differently, and how engineers sometimes arrive at bird-like shapes by a different route.

Time
35 minutes + 10 min homework
Course
Navigation and Technology (ages 14+)
You need
Paper, a pencil and this page
Graded
Instantly, with explanations

Education and interest only. Classfern teaches aviation as a school subject. It is not flight training, not an FAA-approved school, and nothing here counts towards a pilot certificate or replaces training with a certificated instructor and the FAA knowledge test.

How to use this lesson

Sources: Science Learning Hub (How birds fly); National Park Service, Wright Brothers National Memorial ('The Road to the First Flight'); NASA Spinoff on winglets. A good link to biology (adaptation) and design technology. Every answer is graded straight away with a worked explanation.

  1. Read what you will learn and the big ideas.
  2. Press Start the lesson below for the teaching, worked examples and practice (Getting started, On track or Challenge).
  3. Finish with the exit ticket and the talk question: “Can you think of other inventions that copied nature, or that turned out to look like nature only after they were designed?”
  4. Later: the homework, then the practice test.

Watch out for

  • Thinking airplanes fly by copying flapping wings. Success came from separating lift (fixed wing), thrust (propeller) and control.
  • Thinking every bird-like shape on an aircraft was copied from a bird. Winglets came from aerodynamics research; the similarity was noticed afterwards.
  • Thinking birds only make lift on the downstroke and nothing else. The downstroke makes lift and thrust together.

Hands-on: Watch birds in a park or garden for ten minutes. Note which ones flap all the time, which glide and which soar in circles. Then make a paper strip 'wing', hold it by one end and twist the other end up and down – this is the idea behind wing warping.

What you will learn

  • I can explain what biomimicry means.
  • I can describe how birds produce lift and thrust, and how airplanes separate these jobs.
  • I can describe how watching birds helped the Wright brothers solve roll control.
  • I can explain what winglets do, and why looking like a bird's wing is not the same as being copied from one.

Key words

biomimicry
Designing things by learning from how living things work.
wing warping
The Wright brothers' method of twisting the wingtips in opposite directions to roll the aircraft.
winglet
A small upturned surface at a wingtip that weakens the wingtip vortex and reduces drag.
wingtip vortex
A swirl of air that forms at each wingtip as air flows from the high-pressure underside to the low-pressure top.
soaring
Staying aloft without flapping by using rising air, such as thermals.

The big ideas

Biomimicry means learning design ideas from nature. Flight is the most famous example: for centuries people watched birds and tried to copy them. The Science Learning Hub explains that a flapping bird's wing makes both lift and thrust on the downstroke, pushing air downwards and backwards, then partly folds on the upstroke to slip through the air. Birds that glide hold their wings out without flapping, and land birds soar on rising thermals. Light, smooth feathers and largely hollow bones keep weight and drag down.

Early inventors who tried to copy flapping failed. The breakthrough came from separating the jobs: a fixed wing for lift, a propeller for thrust and moving surfaces for control. The gliding pioneer Otto Lilienthal showed that a person could fly a fixed-wing glider, and the Wright brothers used his book. The National Park Service at the Wright Brothers National Memorial says Wilbur's idea of wing warping was 'sparked by his observation of birds and the idle twisting of a box'. Twisting the wings let the Wrights roll their aircraft – the control problem birds had already solved.

Sometimes engineers reach a bird-like shape by their own route. NASA's account of winglets explains that Richard Whitcomb, working at NASA Langley, published his winglet design in 1976 after studying how the air flows round a wingtip. Upturned winglets weaken the wingtip vortices, cut induced drag and save fuel. NASA's article compares the shape to an eagle's wingtip feathers – but the design came from aerodynamics research, not from copying a bird.

Read-through: the teaching steps

  1. What birds do

    Science Learning Hub:

    • Downstroke: lift and thrust together, air pushed down and back
    • Upstroke: wing partly folded to reduce resistance
    • Gliding birds hold their wings out and do no work; land birds soar on thermals
    • Light feathers and largely hollow bones save weight
  2. Why copying flapping failed

    A bird's wing does lift, thrust and control all at once, with muscles far stronger for their weight than early machinery. Flapping machines could not match this. Success came from splitting the jobs between fixed wings, propellers and control surfaces.

  3. What birds did teach

    Gliders showed that a fixed wing can carry a person. Otto Lilienthal made more than 2,500 glider flights; the Wrights used his book. Watching birds twist their wings helped inspire Wilbur Wright's wing warping for roll control.

  4. Winglets: same shape, different route

    At each wingtip, air curls from the high-pressure underside to the low-pressure top, forming a vortex that causes induced drag. Richard Whitcomb at NASA Langley published a winglet design in 1976. NASA says winglets weaken the vortices and reduce fuel use by about 4–6 %. The shape resembles an eagle's wingtip, but it came from aerodynamics research.

  5. Testing the idea

    NASA tested winglets on a KC-135 tanker at its Dryden center in 1977 and found about 7 % better lift-to-drag ratio and about 20 % less induced drag. Airliners such as the Boeing 747-400 and the MD-11 later carried winglets.

The lesson, step by step

35 minutes in 5 parts
PartTimeHow it is checked
Starter: warm up4 minGraded by Classfern
Teaching and hands-on task11 minNot assessed, self-checked
Worked examples and guided practice7 minGraded by Classfern
Independent practice (three levels)8 minGraded by Classfern
Exit ticket and talk question5 minGraded by Classfern, self-checked

Make my lesson plan Opens this lesson in the free Lesson Plan Maker, filled in and ready to change, print or save.

The lesson

It runs here on the page. No sign-up and no names – progress is kept only in this browser.

Homework

About 10 minutes: 6 questions and a one-line reflection, all graded instantly.

More practice

More Big questions lessons · Navigation and Technology course · All aviation practice tests · Aviation Department

Sources and curriculum

Facts in this lesson were checked against:

Our lessons and questions are our own. They are not written or endorsed by the FAA, any flying school, testing agency or exam board.