Case studies: Comet, Tenerife and the Hudson (lessons learned) – Ground School Basics aviation lesson
Lesson 75 of 90 in the Ground School Basics course (ages 11–16)
US version. US spelling and units (inHg, statute miles, US gallons) and the FAA. · UK version
Study three famous events – a metal-fatigue mystery, a runway collision in fog and a river landing – and the safety lessons each one taught.
- Time
- 45 minutes + 10 min homework
- Course
- Ground School Basics (ages 11–16)
- You need
- Paper, a pencil and this page
- Graded
- Instantly, with explanations
Education and interest only. Classfern teaches aviation as a school subject. It is not flight training, not an FAA-approved school, and nothing here counts towards a pilot certificate or replaces training with a certificated instructor and the FAA knowledge test.
For parents: how to use this lesson
These are real accidents in which people died (except the Hudson). The lesson focuses on learning and safety, with no graphic detail. The paper-clip test needs care with sharp ends. Every answer is graded straight away with a worked explanation.
- Read what your child will learn and the big ideas.
- Press Start the lesson below for the teaching, worked examples and practice (Getting started, On track or Challenge).
- Finish with the exit ticket and the talk question: “All three cases led to changes. Which lesson do you think has saved the most lives since, and why?”
- Later: the homework, then the practice test.
Watch out for
- Thinking metal fatigue only happens to old or weak parts. It comes from repeated loading; even strong metal can crack after enough cycles, especially at sharp corners.
- Thinking one person caused Tenerife. Investigators found a chain: congestion, fog, radio interference, unclear phrases and a take-off without clearance.
- Thinking the Hudson outcome was pure luck. Training, teamwork, equipment and rescuers all played a part, as the NTSB found.
Hands-on: Bend a paper clip back and forth, counting each bend, until it snaps. Try several clips and compare the counts. Then try one with a sharp kink already in it. This is metal fatigue – the same thing the Comet investigators discovered.
What your child will learn
- I can describe what investigators found after the Comet accidents and what changed.
- I can explain how misunderstandings on the radio contributed to the Tenerife collision.
- I can explain why everyone survived the Hudson River ditching.
- I can link each case to a lasting safety lesson.
Key words
- metal fatigue
- Cracking caused by a load being applied and removed again and again, even when each load is well below the breaking point.
- pressurization cycle
- One pressurizing and depressurizing of the cabin – roughly one per flight.
- crew resource management (CRM)
- Crew working together, sharing information and questioning doubts, to make safe decisions.
- ditching
- A deliberate emergency landing on water.
- fail-safe design
- Building a structure so that if one part cracks, others carry the load until it is found.
The big ideas
The de Havilland Comet began the world's first jet airliner service in 1952. In January 1954 one broke up near Elba, and in April another came down near Naples. The FAA's lessons-learned library explains what investigators did: they tested a whole fuselage in a water tank, pressurizing it again and again. After about 3,060 cycles it split, starting from a crack at the corner of a squarish window. Metal fatigue from repeated pressurization was the cause. Later airliners got rounded windows and 'fail-safe' structures that could survive a crack.
In March 1977, at Los Rodeos airport on Tenerife, two Boeing 747s collided on a fog-covered runway, killing 583 people – the deadliest accident in aviation history. Traffic had been diverted there after a bomb at Las Palmas. The KLM crew began their take-off without clearance after an unclear exchange ('We are now at take-off') and two radio calls blocked each other. Investigators urged standard, clear phrases and avoiding the word 'take-off' except in a take-off clearance.
In January 2009 an Airbus A320 leaving LaGuardia, New York, hit a flock of birds and lost almost all thrust in both jet engines. The crew ditched in the Hudson River and all 155 people on board survived. The NTSB credited crew decision-making and teamwork, the aircraft's overwater equipment, the cabin crew's fast evacuation and the quick response of nearby rescuers.
Read-through: the teaching steps
Comet: the mystery
Two Comets broke up in 1954 within a few months. Nobody yet knew why. Investigators needed evidence, not guesses.
Comet: the water tank test
A whole fuselage was put in a water tank and repeatedly pressurized to copy flights. After about 3,060 cycles it failed at a window corner. Square corners concentrate stress, and repeated loads grow tiny cracks – metal fatigue.
Comet: what changed
Rounded windows, much more fatigue testing, and 'fail-safe' or damage-tolerant design, where a crack in one part will not bring down the whole structure.
Tenerife: a chain of events
- Diversion crowded a small airport
- Fog cut visibility to about 300 m
- Unclear phrase: 'We are now at take-off'
- Two transmissions at once blocked each other
- Take-off began without clearance
Tenerife: what changed
Investigators called for exact compliance with clearances and standard, concise, unambiguous language. Crews are trained to speak up and question doubtful clearances – a core idea of crew resource management.
The Hudson: why everyone survived
The NTSB pointed to the crew's decision-making and teamwork, an aircraft equipped for overwater flight, a fast evacuation led by the cabin crew, and rescuers who were close by and acted at once.
The lesson, step by step
| Part | Time | How it is checked |
|---|---|---|
| Starter: warm up | 4 min | Graded by Classfern |
| Teaching and hands-on task | 14 min | Not assessed, self-checked |
| Worked examples and guided practice | 9 min | Graded by Classfern |
| Independent practice (three levels) | 13 min | Graded by Classfern |
| Exit ticket and talk question | 5 min | Graded by Classfern, self-checked |
Make my lesson plan Opens this lesson in the free Lesson Plan Maker, filled in and ready to change, print or save.
The lesson
It runs here on the page. No sign-up and no names – progress is kept only in this browser.
Homework
About 10 minutes: 6 questions and a one-line reflection, all graded instantly.
More practice
More Safety and human factors lessons · Ground School Basics course · All aviation practice tests · Aviation Department
Sources and curriculum
Facts in this lesson were checked against:
- FAA Lessons Learned from transport airplane accidents
- https://www.ntsb.gov/news/Pages/Media_Resources.aspx [suggest key NTSB] – NTSB is an independent federal agenc
Our lessons and questions are our own. They are not written or endorsed by the FAA, any flying school, testing agency or exam board.