Energy efficiency: electric cars and petrol cars compared – Garage Basics motor mechanics lesson
Lesson 69 of 70 in the Garage Basics course (ages 11–16)
UK version. UK spelling and words (tyre, petrol, bonnet) and UK rules such as the MOT. · US version
Compare how much of the energy put into an electric car and a petrol car actually reaches the wheels, using US Department of Energy figures and efficiency sums.
- Time
- 45 minutes + 10 min homework
- Course
- Garage Basics (ages 11–16)
- You need
- Paper, a pencil and this page. No tools and no vehicle
- Marked
- Instantly, with explanations
Education and interest only. Classfern teaches motor mechanics as a school subject. It is not a training course or a qualification, and nothing here replaces an IMI or City & Guilds course, an apprenticeship or a qualified technician. Never work on a real vehicle without a qualified adult, the right protective equipment and safe equipment. High-voltage parts of electric and hybrid vehicles are for trained technicians only.
For parents: how to use this lesson
The figures come from US Department of Energy and fueleconomy.gov pages and vary with driving conditions, so they are given as ranges. The activity needs only squared paper. Every answer is marked straight away with a worked explanation.
- Read what your child will learn and the big ideas.
- Press Start the lesson below for the teaching, worked examples and practice (Getting started, On track or Challenge).
- Finish with the exit ticket and the talk question: “If electric cars waste so much less energy, why are petrol cars still made? Think about cost, range, charging and where electricity comes from.”
- Later: the homework, then the practice test.
Watch out for
- Thinking wasted energy is destroyed. Energy is conserved. Wasted energy is dissipated, mostly as heat.
- Thinking an electric car is 100% efficient. It still loses energy in charging, in the motor and electronics, and to accessories.
- Comparing only what happens in the car. A fair comparison also considers how the fuel or electricity was produced and delivered.
Hands-on: On squared paper draw two Sankey diagrams to scale, each starting with an arrow 100 squares wide. Petrol car: 20 squares to the wheels; split the other 80 into engine heat (about 70) and drivetrain and accessories (about 10). Electric car: 69 squares to the wheels; split the other 31 into charging (10), accessories (3) and drive losses (18). Compare the widths.
What your child will learn
- I can define efficiency and calculate it as a percentage.
- I can describe where energy is lost in a petrol car and in an electric car.
- I can compare published efficiency figures for petrol, hybrid and electric cars.
- I can calculate the energy input needed for a given useful output.
- I can explain why the source of electricity matters when comparing cars.
Key words
- efficiency
- Useful energy out ÷ total energy in, usually given as a percentage.
- dissipated
- Spread out into the surroundings, usually as heat, so it can no longer do useful work.
- drive losses
- Energy lost in an electric car's motor, inverter and transmission.
- parasitic loads
- Energy used by parts that keep the car running, such as the coolant pump and the alternator.
- well-to-wheel
- A comparison that includes the energy used to make and deliver the fuel or electricity, not just what happens in the car.
The big ideas
Every car turns stored energy into movement, and every car wastes some of it. The question is how much.
US Department of Energy figures show that only about 20% of the energy released from the fuel in a petrol car reaches the wheels. The rest is lost to engine inefficiency, drivetrain friction and parasitic loads such as the coolant pump and the alternator. An electric car does much better: fueleconomy.gov reports that in combined driving 65–69% of the energy taken from the charger reaches the wheels, or 87–91% when the energy recovered by regenerative braking is counted. Hybrids sit in between.
In this lesson you will compare these figures, practise efficiency sums, and think about what the figures leave out.
Read-through: the teaching steps
What efficiency means
Efficiency = useful energy out ÷ total energy in × 100%.
Energy is never destroyed, so useful energy + wasted energy = total energy in. A car that is 20% efficient wastes 80% of its energy, mostly as heat.
The petrol car
In a petrol car, the chemical energy in the fuel is released by burning. Most of it heats the engine and the exhaust gases. fueleconomy.gov gives engine losses of 64–75% for a petrol car. More is lost in the gearbox and to parasitic loads. US Department of Energy figures show about 20% of the fuel's energy reaches the wheels. Follow the path in the drawing on the lesson page.
How the turning force gets from the engine to the driven wheels (rear-wheel drive shown). The electric car
fueleconomy.gov breaks down an electric car's energy in combined driving:
- charging losses: about 10%
- accessories: about 3%
- drive losses (motor, inverter, transmission): about 18%
- to the wheels: 65–69%, or 87–91% counting regenerative braking
Electric drive losses are 15–20%, against 64–75% engine losses in a petrol car. Electric motors simply waste far less as heat.
The main parts of a battery electric car. High-voltage parts (usually with orange cables) are for trained technicians only. The hybrid
A hybrid still burns fuel, but its motor helps the engine work at its most efficient and recovers braking energy. fueleconomy.gov gives hybrids 65–69% engine losses in combined driving, with 24–38% of the energy reaching the wheels and 5–9% recovered by regenerative braking.
City and highway
Driving style changes the figures. fueleconomy.gov says an electric car returns about 32% of its energy by regenerative braking in the city but only about 6% on the highway, because there is less braking to recover. Petrol cars, by contrast, are least efficient in stop-start traffic, where engines idle and work at light loads.
What the figures leave out
These figures start at the fuel tank or the charger. A full comparison – sometimes called well-to-wheel – also counts the energy used to produce and deliver the fuel, and to generate and transmit the electricity. Some power stations burn fuel and lose much of its energy as heat; wind and solar do not burn anything. The US Department of Energy notes that emissions from plug-in vehicles depend on the electricity source.
The lesson, step by step
| Part | Time | How it is checked |
|---|---|---|
| Starter: warm up | 4 min | Marked by Classfern |
| Teaching and hands-on task | 14 min | Not assessed, self-checked |
| Worked examples and guided practice | 9 min | Marked by Classfern |
| Independent practice (three levels) | 13 min | Marked by Classfern |
| Exit ticket and talk question | 5 min | Marked by Classfern, self-checked |
Make my lesson plan Opens this lesson in the free Lesson Plan Maker, filled in and ready to change, print or save.
The lesson
It runs here on the page. No sign-up and no names – progress is kept only in this browser.
Homework
About 10 minutes: 6 questions and a one-line reflection, all marked instantly.
More practice
More Electric and hybrid basics lessons · Garage Basics course · All motor mechanics practice tests · Motor Mechanics Department
Sources and curriculum
Facts in this lesson were checked against:
- US Department of Energy and EPA, fueleconomy.gov – Where the energy goes: electric cars
- US Department of Energy, Alternative Fuels Data Center – How do all-electric cars work?
- US Department of Energy, Alternative Fuels Data Center – How do gasoline cars work?
- US Department of Energy, Alternative Fuels Data Center – Energy losses in light-duty gasoline vehicles
Our lessons and questions are our own. They are not written or endorsed by the DVSA, the IMI, City & Guilds, any college, testing agency or exam board.