▶ TrainingGet Pro
All tools & lessonsAll toolsAllGet the appApp
Learning departments Music, Maths, Cookery, Programming and Art are open – explore →

Lift explained 2: turning the airflow (Newton) and why equal transit time is a myth – Ground School Basics aviation lesson

Lesson 4 of 90 in the Ground School Basics course (ages 11–16)

UK version. UK spelling and units (hPa, metres, litres) and the UK CAA. · US version

A wing makes lift by turning a moving flow of air downwards – and the air pushes the wing up. Use Newton's laws and momentum to explain lift, and see clearly why the 'equal transit time' story fails.

Time
45 minutes + 10 min homework
Course
Ground School Basics (ages 11–16)
You need
Paper, a pencil and this page
Marked
Instantly, with explanations

Education and interest only. Classfern teaches aviation as a school subject. It is not flight training, not an approved training organisation, and nothing here counts towards a pilot licence or replaces a CAA-approved course and the CAA’s own exams.

For parents: how to use this lesson

This is GCSE/high-school physics: Newton's second and third laws and momentum. Supervise the spoon-and-tap demonstration near water. Every answer is marked straight away with a worked explanation.

  1. Read what your child will learn and the big ideas.
  2. Press Start the lesson below for the teaching, worked examples and practice (Getting started, On track or Challenge).
  3. Finish with the exit ticket and the talk question: “A helicopter's rotor blades and a bird's wings also turn air downwards. What would you expect to feel standing underneath a hovering helicopter, and why?”
  4. Later: the homework, then the practice test.

Watch out for

  • Thinking only the bottom of the wing pushes the air down, like a skimming stone. The upper surface also turns the flow downwards. Ignoring it gives a wrong answer for how much lift is made.
  • Thinking the Newton explanation proves Bernoulli wrong (or the other way round). Both describe the same flow correctly. Only the equal-transit-time reasoning is wrong.
  • Thinking a wing could make lift in space if it moved fast enough. Lift needs a fluid to turn. In a vacuum there is nothing to push on.

Hands-on: Hold the back of a spoon loosely so it hangs under a gently running tap, with the curved back just touching the stream of water. Watch the water follow the curve and be thrown sideways, and feel the spoon pulled into the stream – the reaction to turning the flow.

What your child will learn

  • I can explain lift as the reaction to a wing turning the airflow downwards (Newton's third law).
  • I can use force = rate of change of momentum to estimate lift.
  • I can explain why both wing surfaces help to turn the flow.
  • I can give three reasons why the equal-transit-time explanation is wrong.
  • I can explain that there is no lift without moving air.

Key words

downwash
The air leaving the back of a wing, turned downwards by the wing.
Newton's third law
When one object exerts a force on another, the second exerts an equal and opposite force on the first.
momentum
Mass × velocity (kg m/s). A force changes an object's momentum.
rate of change of momentum
Change in momentum ÷ time taken. By Newton's second law, it equals the resultant force.
relative airflow
The air moving past the wing, which exists whether the wing moves through still air or air blows past a still wing.

The big ideas

NASA's Beginner's Guide to Aeronautics puts it simply: lift occurs when a moving flow of gas is turned by a solid object. The flow is turned one way, and the lift acts in the opposite direction, as Newton's third law says. A wing moving through the air turns a large mass of air downwards behind it – the downwash – and the air pushes the wing upwards.

Both surfaces take part. The lower surface deflects air downwards, and the air flowing over the curved upper surface follows it and is also turned downwards as it leaves the trailing edge. NASA warns that ignoring the upper surface leads to an incorrect theory. The amount of turning depends on the wing's shape and its angle of attack.

Newton's second law lets us estimate the size of the force: force equals the rate of change of momentum. If a wing gives each second's worth of air a downward velocity, the lift is about the mass of air turned per second multiplied by the downward speed given to it. This picture explains things the equal-transit-time story cannot: flat wings, wings flying upside down and why lift needs moving air. The pressure-difference picture from the last lesson describes the same flow from the wing's point of view.

Read-through: the teaching steps

  1. Turn the flow, get a force

    A wing turns the moving air downwards. By Newton's third law, the air pushes the wing upwards with an equal and opposite force. Look at the wing section drawing on the lesson page and imagine the air leaving the trailing edge angled down.

    Relative airflowAngle of attackLeading edgeTrailing edgeCamber line (dashed)Chord line
    An aerofoil: the chord line joins the leading and trailing edges; the angle of attack is between the chord line and the relative airflow.
  2. Both surfaces turn the air

    • The lower surface deflects air downwards
    • Air over the upper surface follows the curve and leaves the trailing edge heading downwards too

    Leaving out the upper surface gives a wrong theory.

  3. Force = rate of change of momentum

    Newton's second law: F = change in momentum ÷ time.

    For a wing, lift ≈ (mass of air turned each second) × (downward speed given to it). A bigger wing, faster flight or a larger angle of attack turns more air, or turns it more.

  4. No air, no lift

    Lift comes from the difference in velocity between the wing and the air. With no fluid, or no relative movement, there is nothing to turn and no lift – which is why wings are useless in space.

  5. Why equal transit time fails

    • The air parcels that split at the leading edge do not meet again; the upper air arrives first
    • A flat paper wing with equal top and bottom lengths flies
    • Aeroplanes can fly upside down

    The turning-flow picture explains all three.

  6. One flow, two descriptions

    Pressure differences on the wing are how the wing pushes the air down; the downward-turned air is the evidence. Bernoulli and Newton are not rivals – they are two correct ways of describing the same event.

The lesson, step by step

45 minutes in 5 parts
PartTimeHow it is checked
Starter: warm up4 minMarked by Classfern
Teaching and hands-on task14 minNot assessed, self-checked
Worked examples and guided practice9 minMarked by Classfern
Independent practice (three levels)13 minMarked by Classfern
Exit ticket and talk question5 minMarked by Classfern, self-checked

Make my lesson plan Opens this lesson in the free Lesson Plan Maker, filled in and ready to change, print or save.

The lesson

It runs here on the page. No sign-up and no names – progress is kept only in this browser.

Homework

About 10 minutes: 6 questions and a one-line reflection, all marked instantly.

More practice

More Physics of flight lessons · Ground School Basics course · All aviation practice tests · Aviation Department

Sources and curriculum

Facts in this lesson were checked against:

Our lessons and questions are our own. They are not written or endorsed by the CAA, any flying school, testing agency or exam board.